Village Square Pizza - Midtown

Stanley Spall 3 months ago

Very nice, warm pizza. Almost too hot to eat! Quaint little setup but would recommend for a good slice.

Amy Cole 3 months ago

The vodka pepperoni slice was delicious. The buffalo chicken slice needed some additional sauce on it such as blue cheese and hot sauce. The crust was a mid height crust and good bottom. Has some counter and stools to eat but it was very hot with no AC, so I'd recommend taking it to go.

Linda Cheng 4 months ago

Love this spot ! The first time I’ve been was at their east village location! Now they have expand to multiple locations and stopped by here at night for a quick dinner before movies and it was still as good! I got to try their new vodka pepperoni and sausage pepper slice and few others! The staff there Jose and Christian was super friendly !stop by and visit them!

EE Grimshaw 9 months ago

***3 1/2 stars*** I'm always a little leery of this area that tends to cater to the tourist demographic (which was alive and thriving when I arrived - an out-of-towner father of two gleefully purchased a $1 ranch side and practically shouted his thank yous as he walked away from the counter), but this place is a bit under the radar given where it is, and ultimately provides a quality slice. I stumbled across Village Square a few days ago after almost getting lost in that horrendous hellscape known as the holiday markets over by Herald Square. Given that it's literally a half block from Macy's, it's stunning how subtle the location is - it's tucked away between a few other nondescript businesses and could easily be overlooked if you didn't notice the signage. When I came back to try Village Square for lunch, it was pretty empty, save the aforementioned tourists and a few people waiting for pickup orders. There's only a few stools and metal countertops along the walls, so it's not the most comfortable eatery to spend your lunch in, but it is what it is. Honestly, pizza optics are important to me and I thought the tomato sauce-based slices looked a little sketchy. The vodka square

Trisha T 10 months ago

We wanted to grab a quick bite before a game and discovered this pizza spot. It looks like a regular pizza place from the outside but when you walk in it smells amazing and is very clean. We got to chat with the owner who told us a little about the place and where in Italy he was from. Super nice. You could tell that quality is important to him. When he took a pie out of the oven the crust was a little too dark for his standards so he actually offered free slices to us folks eating inside. Personally I like my crusts crunchy so I was happy. I got the grandma slice and it was delicious. Definitely would to back.